• About
    • What We Do
    • Advocacy
    • Heritage Update
    • Plans and Reports
    • Membership
    • Donate
    • Sponsors
    • Board of Directors
    • Staff
  • Events & Activities
    • 2022 Conference
    • BC Heritage Awards
    • Heritage Week
    • Dates to Know
  • Learning Centre
    • ICH: Creating a Community-Based Inventory
    • Intangible Cultural Heritage
    • Climate Adaptation: Making a Case
    • Climate Adaptation: Framework and Implementation
    • Setting the Bar: A Reconciliation Guide for Heritage
    • A Guide to Making a Case for Heritage
    • Heritage Conservation Tools: Resource Guides
    • Webinars On-Demand
    • Heritage Workshops
    • Other Heritage Education Programs
  • Cultural Maps
    • Submerged Heritage Resources
    • Columbia Basin Region Heritage Places
    • Francophone Historic Places Map
    • Chinese Canadian Historic Places Map
    • Japanese Canadian Historic Places
    • South Asian Canadian Map
    • War Monuments and Memorials Map
    • Mapping Heritage
  • Resources
    • Accessibility for Historic Places
    • Conservation in BC Reports
    • Definitions and Heritage FAQs
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Heritage Real Estate
    • State of Heritage: Provincial Roundtables
    • Indigenous Cultural Heritage
    • Local Government: Library of Source Documents
    • Racism: Do Not Let the Forgetting Prevail
    • Heritage Quick Studies
    • Other Tools, Publications, Guides
  • Heritage Legacy Fund
    • Heritage Legacy Fund Review
    • Who Benefits?
    • Past Grant Recipients
    • Climate Disaster Response Fund
  • Job Board
    • Job Hunting Resources
    • Job Postings
    • Submit a Job
  • Contact
  • Membership
  • Donate
  • Newsletter
Heritage BC
Membership Donate Newsletter
  • About

    About

    • What We Do
    • Advocacy
    • Heritage Update
    • Plans and Reports
    • Membership
    • Donate
    • Sponsors
    • Board of Directors
    • Staff
  • Events & Activities

    Events & Activities

    • 2022 Conference
    • BC Heritage Awards
    • Heritage Week
    • Dates to Know
  • Learning Centre

    Learning Centre

    • ICH: Creating a Community-Based Inventory
    • Intangible Cultural Heritage
    • Climate Adaptation: Making a Case
    • Climate Adaptation: Framework and Implementation
    • Setting the Bar: A Reconciliation Guide for Heritage
    • A Guide to Making a Case for Heritage
    • Heritage Conservation Tools: Resource Guides
    • Webinars On-Demand
    • Heritage Workshops
    • Other Heritage Education Programs
  • Cultural Maps

    Cultural Maps

    • Submerged Heritage Resources
    • Columbia Basin Region Heritage Places
    • Francophone Historic Places Map
    • Chinese Canadian Historic Places Map
    • Japanese Canadian Historic Places
    • South Asian Canadian Map
    • War Monuments and Memorials Map
    • Mapping Heritage
  • Resources

    Resources

    • Accessibility for Historic Places
    • Conservation in BC Reports
    • Definitions and Heritage FAQs
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Heritage Real Estate
    • State of Heritage: Provincial Roundtables
    • Indigenous Cultural Heritage
    • Local Government: Library of Source Documents
    • Racism: Do Not Let the Forgetting Prevail
    • Heritage Quick Studies
    • Other Tools, Publications, Guides
  • Heritage Legacy Fund

    Heritage Legacy Fund

    • Heritage Legacy Fund Review
    • Who Benefits?
    • Past Grant Recipients
    • Climate Disaster Response Fund
  • Job Board

    Job Board

    • Job Hunting Resources
    • Job Postings
    • Submit a Job
  • Contact
  • 2022 Conference
    • Program Schedule
    • Culture & Heritage SLAM! 2022
    • Sponsors
    • Conference Archive
      • 2021 Heritage BC Conference
        • Sponsors
      • 2020 Heritage BC Conference
      • 2019 Heritage BC Conference
      • 2018 Heritage BC Conference
      • 2017 Heritage BC Conference
  • BC Heritage Awards
    • 2022 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2021 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2020 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2019 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2018 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2017 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2016 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2014 Heritage Award Recipients
    • 2013 Heritage Award Recipients
  • Heritage Week
    • Heritage Week: Altogether Inclusive (2022)
  • Dates to Know
  • Events & Activities
  • The Heritage BC Watch List

Watch List: Post War, Modern or Twentieth Century Heritage

“The recent past falls into limbo – too young to be classed as heritage and too dated to be current and cutting edge. Insufficient time has passed to allow a sense of legacy and value to mature. In a world with an already short attention span, and an increasingly disposable society, it is yesterday’s past that is at greatest risk.” (World Monuments Fund)

All eras have been marked with innovation and development, at least relative to the time, but the Twentieth Century experienced a level of unprecedented change unlike any preceding period.

Watch List: Introduction

Institutional Heritage

Industrial Heritage

Schools

Churches

Vernacular Heritage

Learn More / Nominate Site

At least in part, this is due to the great events that shaped the world, but new technologies, inventions and innovations have also pushed architects, designers and builders to consider design and construction in ways that had previously been inconceivable.

The Twentieth Century was also a period of rapidly changing tastes and one generation soon rejected what the preceding generation had embraced.

Perhaps this rejection has led to under-appreciation for much architecture and style, but also society does not seem to be ready to define ‘modern’ architecture as heritage, even if this period has spanned roughly 100 years.

“Many of these buildings have not aged well. The new and innovative construction methods and materials that typify the era challenge traditional conservation approaches and raise new methodological and philosophical issues. Despite increased recognition of modern architecture’s cultural significance, there is a lack of practical conservation knowledge that addresses the many complex challenges. Effectively tackling these issues demands leadership, strategic research, and brokering with industry to develop appropriate repair techniques that translate research into practice and achieve conservation aims. A concerted effort to bring together and distribute existing information as well as identify and fill information gaps is also needed.” (The Getty Conservation Institute)

While for many a 1950’s building does not elicit the same emotional and visceral response as a 1850s building, the more recent building is still part of the long lineage of design and aesthetics that describe time and society.

Modernism is not a new concept, but has been with us for over 100 years. Major architectural statements and styles have defined the Twentieth Century and have shaped new ways of living and relating to the environment.

The concept of heritage is not fixed in time, but it is ever expanding. It will be critical to recognize and accept heritage as an evolving practice, and to recognize the architectural achievements of the Twentieth Century, before it is too late and we no longer have the important markers of our recent cultural heritage.

Challenges facing Post War, Modern or Twentieth Century Heritage

  • Weak legal protections
  • Low appreciation among professionals, planners and public
  • Many materials are not easily maintained; unusual combinations of materials challenge typical conservation methods; materials age at different rates
  • Much Twentieth Century architecture is considered to be too recent to be heritage
  • Increasingly short-term, disposable society
  • Buildings have not aged well
  • Lack of leadership, strategic research, and appropriate repair techniques

About Vancouver Public Library Collingwood Branch

(from Vancouver Heritage Foundation’s Places That Matter)

VPL Collingwood Branch
City of Vancouver Archives
COV-S62-CVA 296-047

The Collingwood library opened on the corner of Rupert and Kingsway in July 1951, part of a push to expand the Vancouver Public Library system beyond its seven branches at a time when the city as growing out from the core. Shortly after its opening, the branch is said to have recorded the highest circulation of children’s books of any branch in the Vancouver Public Library system. For many years the Collingwood library was the home of the bookmobile providing a mobile book service to outlying neighbourhoods.

Designed by Vancouver architects Harold Semmens and Douglas Simpson, the striking modern library building was a light and open structure, reflecting contemporary ideas of openness and accessibility. “This was the first example of Modernist architecture in the Vancouver Public Library system,” according to Heritage Vancouver. The design was intended to make library services more accessible and inviting, in contrast to the “closed, intimidating style of some older branches like the Carnegie Library at Hastings and Main. The Semmens and Simpson partnership was an intense but short-lived collaboration that produced some of the finest modernist buildings in Canada. Their designs won the firm the Massey Medal for Architecture more than once. Because of the success of the Collingwood branch, Semmens and Simpson received the commission to design the new main branch of the library at Burrard and Robson Streets in 1953-57.

The Issues

The modernist 1950s aesthetic of VPL’s Collingwood Branch has largely been lost due to a number of unsympathetic alterations.

The façade has been significantly altered with the application of large blue panels covering the east end of the building and obscuring full-height glazing. The same siding has been used to cover second-floor area (west end); exterior stairs, fencing and a utility door have also been added to this upper area.

Heritage Vancouver added the library to its 2011 Watch List, urging restoration of the façade, preparation of a Statement of Significance, and entry on the Vancouver Heritage Register. These have not been accomplished as of 2018.

Sources:

  • https://whc.unesco.org/en/modernheritage/
  • http://www.getty.edu/conservation/our_projects/field_projects/cmai/cmai_brochure.pdf
  • http://www.getty.edu/conservation/our_projects/field_projects/cmai/cmai_related_mats.html
  • https://wmf.org.uk/news/looking-after-the-recent-past/
  • http://www.vancouverheritagefoundation.org/place-that-matters/collingwood-branch/
Explore 150 Time Immemorial Grant Program Projects
2022 BC Heritage Awards Winners
Download a Webinar-On-Demand

Support Us

Membership Donate
Heritage BC

604-417-7243

PO Box 846
Ladysmith, BC
V9G 1A6

Connect with Us

© 2022 Heritage BC.
Website by SplitMango

As an organization of provincial scope, Heritage BC recognizes that its members, and the local history and heritage they seek to preserve, occupy the lands and territories of B.C.’s Indigenous peoples. Heritage BC asks its members and everyone working in the heritage sector to reflect on the places where they reside and work, and to respect the diversity of cultures and experiences that form the richness of our provincial heritage.