• About
    • What We Do
    • Membership
    • Our Advocacy
    • Newsletter
    • Donate
    • Board of Directors
    • Staff
    • Plans and Reports
    • Sponsors
  • Events & Activities
    • Heritage BC Conference 2023
    • BC Heritage Awards
    • Heritage Week 2023
    • Dates to Know
  • Learning Centre
    • Heritage 101
    • Advocacy
    • Accessibility for Historic Places
    • Climate & Sustainability
    • Heritage Place Conservation
    • Heritage Policy & Legislation
    • Homeowners
    • Intangible Cultural Heritage
    • Non-For-Profit Organizations
    • Reconciliation
    • Webinars On-Demand
  • Cultural Maps
    • Mapping Heritage
    • Submerged Heritage Resources
    • Columbia Basin Region Heritage Places
    • Francophone Historic Places Map
    • Chinese Canadian Historic Places Map
    • Japanese Canadian Historic Places
    • South Asian Canadian Map
    • War Monuments and Memorials Map
  • Funding
    • Heritage Legacy Fund
    • Government Funded Grants
    • Climate Disaster Response Fund
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Additional Funding Resources
    • Grant Writing Webinar
  • News
  • Professional Development
    • Educational Opportunities
    • Job Hunting Resources
    • Submit a Job
    • Job Board
    • Annual Conference
    • Professional Organizations
  • Contact
  • Membership
  • Donate
  • Newsletter
Heritage BC
Membership Donate Newsletter
  • About

    About

    • What We Do
    • Membership
    • Our Advocacy
    • Newsletter
    • Donate
    • Board of Directors
    • Staff
    • Plans and Reports
    • Sponsors
  • Events & Activities

    Events & Activities

    • Heritage BC Conference 2023
    • BC Heritage Awards
    • Heritage Week 2023
    • Dates to Know
  • Learning Centre

    Learning Centre

    • Heritage 101
    • Advocacy
    • Accessibility for Historic Places
    • Climate & Sustainability
    • Heritage Place Conservation
    • Heritage Policy & Legislation
    • Homeowners
    • Intangible Cultural Heritage
    • Non-For-Profit Organizations
    • Reconciliation
    • Webinars On-Demand
  • Cultural Maps

    Cultural Maps

    • Mapping Heritage
    • Submerged Heritage Resources
    • Columbia Basin Region Heritage Places
    • Francophone Historic Places Map
    • Chinese Canadian Historic Places Map
    • Japanese Canadian Historic Places
    • South Asian Canadian Map
    • War Monuments and Memorials Map
  • Funding

    Funding

    • Heritage Legacy Fund
    • Government Funded Grants
    • Climate Disaster Response Fund
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Additional Funding Resources
    • Grant Writing Webinar
  • News
  • Professional Development

    Professional Development

    • Educational Opportunities
    • Job Hunting Resources
    • Submit a Job
    • Job Board
    • Annual Conference
    • Professional Organizations
  • Contact
  • Heritage 101
    • Heritage Quick Studies
    • Definitions and Heritage FAQs
    • Organizations to Know
  • Advocacy
    • A Guide to Making a Case for Heritage
    • Election Resources
    • Reports : Heritage Conservation in BC
    • State of Heritage: Provincial Roundtables
    • Heritage Week
  • Accessibility for Historic Places
  • Climate & Sustainability
    • Building Resilience and Sustainability
    • Climate Adaptation : Making A Case Resource Guide
    • Climate Adaptation: Framework and Implementation
    • Seismic Risk & British Columbia’s Historic Streetscapes
  • Heritage Place Conservation
    • Heritage Conservation Tools: Resource Guides
      • Community Heritage Commissions
      • Community Heritage Register
      • Heritage Conservation Areas
      • Heritage Designation
      • Heritage Revitalization Agreements
    • Conservation in BC : Reports and Factsheets
    • Heritage Real Estate
      • Insuring Heritage Properties
    • Publications on Heritage Place Conservation Practices
  • Heritage Policy & Legislation
    • Heritage Legislation in BC
    • Local Government: Library of Source Documents
    • Heritage Conservation Tools: Resource Guides
  • Homeowners
    • Building Code, Heritage Standards & Laws
    • Heritage Designation
    • Heritage Professionals
    • Energy Improvements & Sustainability
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Insurance
    • Materials, Construction & Design
    • Heritage Building Maintenance
    • Safety & Hazardous Materials
  • Intangible Cultural Heritage
    • Intangible Cultural Heritage: A Resource Guide
    • ICH: Creating a Community-Based Inventory
  • Non-For-Profit Organizations
    • Organizational Capacity Building
    • Heritage Tourism
    • A Compendium of Tips and Information for Governance, Management and NFP Operations
  • Reconciliation
    • Indigenous Cultural Heritage
    • Setting the Bar: A Reconciliation Guide for Heritage
      • 1. Heritage and Reconciliation Pledge
      • 2. Acknowledging Land and People
      • 3. Celebrating Days of Recognition and Commemoration
      • 4. With a Commitment to Learn
      • 5. Committing to Strategic Organizational Diversity
      • 6. Mission-Making Room for Reconciliation
      • 7. Possession, Interpretation, Repatriation and Cultural Care
      • 8. Shared Decision Making
      • 9. Statements of Significance and other heritage planning documents
      • 10. Heritage Conservation Tools, Local Government Act
    • Racism: Do Not Let the Forgetting Prevail
      • Erasure 2.0: Gatekeepers
      • Why should we remember?  The legacy of remembrance
      • Racism is like an addiction
      • Black Lives Do Matter
      • The Powerful Position of Learning
      • Beyond Acknowledgement to Diversity and Inclusion
      • Erasure: A Statement on Racism, Inclusivity and Equity
      • Taking Action: resources for diversity and inclusion
  • Webinars On-Demand
  • Learning Centre
  • Advocacy
  • A Guide to Making a Case for Heritage

Making a Case for Heritage: Building Conservation

Retrofitting old buildings may be the most important action to mitigate climate change.

This section will help you to describe the importance of building conservation.

The first section provides impressive statistics to back up your case.

The second section provides ideas to help you to develop your local case.

Retention and conservation make good environmental sense

Buildings have been identified as the largest single source of energy use, waste, and omissions into the atmosphere. Close to half of the greenhouse gases produced in Canada come from buildings.

Buildings are vast storerooms of energy
It takes energy to extract raw materials from the earth and energy to manufacture finished building materials, more energy to transport those materials to a construction site, and still more energy to assemble the building. All of this energy, the total energy required to produce and maintain the building over its entire lifecycle is known as embodied energy. If a building is demolished and taken to the landfill, the embodied energy is wasted. There is a tremendous impact on the environment when something new is built. Avoiding new construction by retaining and reusing heritage buildings is an ecologically conscious decision.

Buildings are producers of carbon
Carbon emitted through building construction, including the entire process of extraction, fabrication, transportation, and assembly is called embodied carbon. When an existing building is demolished and a new building is erected, the carbon footprint is much larger than that of a retrofitted or rehabilitated building, in which its life-cycle carbon is largely already spent.

New buildings do not provide simple answers
While new buildings meeting today’s highest energy efficiency standards typically consume less energy for heating and cooling than older buildings without energy-saving retrofits, demolition of a heritage building ignores the fact that many new building materials require a tremendous amount of energy to produce and most cannot be reused or recycled.

Impacts in numbers

  • It takes a lot of energy to construct a building. For example, building a 50,000 square foot (4645 m2) commercial building requires the same amount of energy it takes to drive a car 20,000 miles (32,187 kilometres) a year for 730 years.
  • Recent research shows that it takes 35 to 50 years for an energy efficient, new building to save the amount of energy lost in demolishing an existing building.
  • It is known that “even the most energy-efficient new building cannot offset its embodied energy for many years. The United Nations Energy Programme estimates that the embodied energy of a building is 20% if a building is operational for 100 years… the shorter the service life, the greater the ratio of embodied energy to operating energy is”.
  • In fact, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), “… over the whole building stock, the largest portion of carbon savings by 2030 is in retrofitting existing buildings and replacing energy-using equipment…”
  • Approximately 25% of Canada’s waste stream, is made up of construction, renovation and demolition waste.
  • Demolition projects produce 20 -30 times more waste material per square meter than renovation or construction projects.
  • According to the Building Materials Reuse Assoc., demolishing a 2,000 square-foot house, for example, sends 60 tons of material to the landfill, 85% of which could have been reused.
  • 20% of all Canadian landfill is occupied by used construction material
  • 50% of construction waste is salvageable and reusable
  • 45% of construction waste is recyclable

Analyzing available Canadian data, Parks Canada provided the following information in the report “Historic Places Matter”:

  • The embodied energy of a building increases by 144% by the time it is 50 years old.
  • Refurbishing buildings could reduce Canada’s waste stream by approximately 6%.
  • The energy consumption of existing renovated buildings is relatively similar to the energy consumption for a typical new building.

But, action is needed

It is estimated that more than 20% of Canada’s built heritage was lost between 1970 and 2000. (Heritage Research Associates Inc., CIHB Revisited, 1999)


Heritage conservation and sustainable development are not synonymous movements, but they align where it matters most: in their mutual passion for enhancing the relationships people have with their built environments. Sustainability concerns people and change, and heritage does not dwell on the past but seeks to understand today and the future.

Use the intrinsic-instrumental-institutional framework to develop a well-rounded case for building conservation. Here are some suggestions to help you get started. (Read this short introduction to our recommended approach to making a case.)

Intrinsic

What are people saying about specific buildings and heritage areas?

  • Capture comments about the impact and importance of the built environment in your community. Ask people for their most treasured memories (make a contest out of it by awarding a prize for the best story).
  • If you have youth outreach programs, ask the young people to draw pictures of buildings they love and ask them to describe why the buildings are important.
  • Know the history of the buildings around you and how they helped to create your community. Also, know the success stories of conservation, revitalization, rejuvenation, and reuse. Better yet, get people to describe it for you.
  • Consider community surveys that ask people to describe their association with your heritage district. Ask people to vote for their favourite buildings; this will give you a list of buildings that are considered to be important.

Instrumental

Use the proceeding section and the sources to convey irrefutable evidence of the relationship between heritage conservation and environmental sustainability.

Institutional

In this case, you may want to consider how the built environment adds value to your community.

  • Consider the social and economic aspects. How does heritage make your community more attractive and liveable? How does heritage support the economy (e.g. affordable housing, sustained housing market, tourism draw). How does the regional district, local government, Chamber of Commerce (and other organizations) use heritage to describe your community as an attractive place to live or visit?

New South Wales Heritage Branch. “Heritage & Sustainability: A Discussion Paper” January 2004, Pg. 9
Building Resilience: Practical Guidelines For The Sustainable Rehabilitation Of Buildings In Canada (source)
National Trust for Historic Preservation, “ Sustainability by Numbers,” (source)
“U.S. Life Cycle Inventory Database.” (2012). National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2012. Accessed November 19, 2012 (source)
Carroon, Jean. 2010. Sustainable Preservation: Greening Existing Buildings.New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons Inc.: 7.
Construction and Demolition Waste Recycling: A Literature Review. Dalhousie University Office of Sustainability, 2011
Vancouver Heritage Foundation Green Guide (source)
Construction and Demolition Waste Recycling: A Literature Review. Dalhousie University Office of Sustainability, 2011 (source)

Setting the Bar | Governor's Awards 2022 Recipient
Join Heritage Week 2023
NEW! Homeowner Resources

Support Us

Membership Donate
Heritage BC

604-417-7243

PO Box 846
Ladysmith, BC
V9G 1A6

Connect with Us

© 2023 Heritage BC.
Website by SplitMango

As an organization of provincial scope, Heritage BC recognizes that its members, and the local history and heritage they seek to preserve, occupy the lands and territories of B.C.’s Indigenous peoples. Heritage BC asks its members and everyone working in the heritage sector to reflect on the places where they reside and work, and to respect the diversity of cultures and experiences that form the richness of our provincial heritage.